Will Banning Plastic Bags Help?

The Two Sides of the Debate Over Plastic Bag Bans 

When discussing the benefits and drawbacks of imposing plastic bag ban is in question, there is one specific thing that is written in stone, the opposition on the idea of a disposable plastic bag ban is not possible. Although there are some plastic bags that can be recycled, it is a very small percentage that can be recycled. A significant number of plastic bags become a source of plastic pollution that contaminates nature and threatens the health and safety of wildlife.

The use of reusable polypropylene (PP) bags, on the other hand, can help in repurposing post-industrial or pre-consumer recycled materials and hugely reduce the production of single-use waste. These reusable bags are not only long-lasting but can also be washed and reused multiple times. Doing so majorly reduces the environmental footprint created by everyday shopping. These arguments will be discussed below in extensive detail. 

A major number of plastic bags end up in landfills or as litter. Despite all measures and numeric calculations, plastic bags never biodegrade safely and breakdown into microplastics. These remain in the environment for centuries and end up costing a lot of money and resources for cleanup and waste management services. Individuals or organisations who are against the banning of plastic bags take effort to minimize the harmful after-effects. But when taking a closer look, it is evident that a major number of opposers who support the use of plastic bags are outmanevuered by the economic and environmental effects of ending plastic bag usage.
 

Want your child to write with clarity and conviction like this?
Help them learn how to structure logical arguments, present both sides of a topic, and write persuasively with PlanetSpark’s English Writing Course.
Book a Free Trial Class Today!

Advantages of Plastic Bag Bans 

1. Boost to the Economy

Although there are claims which say that the elimination of plastic bag production may impact manufacturers, the change in demand can increase the opportunities of producing eco-friendly and sustainable products. The increased demands for reusable bags can then lead to a increase in the production and manufacture of bags made with canvas, cloth or other recyclable materials. Such a step in turn creates new  green jobs and supports local businesses. Therefore, it cna be easily understood that ban on plastic bags can stimulate the economy

2. Reduced Retail and Consumer Costs 

When pricing their products, it is often observed that retailers include the cost free plastic bags at the time of selling a product to their customers. Once removed from circulation, the stores can pass on the savinsg to their customers. There have been multiple studies that have shown that buyers can save approximately 1500 to 2500 INR per year when plastic bags are phased out and replaced with reusable options. This is helps in understanding that the elimination of plastic bags aids in reducing the cost of the products that you will buy.

3. Environmental pollution is reduced

As plastic bags are not biodegradable, they disintegrate into microplastics that go on to pollute the air, water and soil. It further goes into oceans, rivers, cities, communities, farmlands and other areas which leads to concerning ecological and health issues. The ban of plastic bags reduces the volume of plastic garbage that is produced along with the lowered visual and ecological pollutions caused due to it.

4. Conservation of Tax Dollars

Cleaning up plastic bag litter costs municipalities millions in tax revenue annually. This includes the cost of labor, waste management systems, street sweeping, and landfill maintenance. By reducing plastic bag waste, governments can redirect these public funds toward more pressing needs such as education, healthcare, or infrastructure.

5. Protection for Marine Life

Marine ecosystems suffer immensely from plastic bag waste. Sea turtles, dolphins, whales, and many fish species often mistake plastic bags for jellyfish or plankton. Ingesting these bags can lead to blockages, internal injuries, malnutrition, and ultimately death. By eliminating plastic bags from the environment, we provide safer habitats and healthier oceans.

6. Better Functioning Drainage Systems

Plastic litter is one of the primary culprits behind blocked drainage systems. Urban areas are especially vulnerable to this kind of blockage, which can result in avoidable flooding, property damage, and health hazards. Banning plastic bags helps to keep drainage systems clear and cities safer during heavy rains.

7. Reduced Dependency on Fossil Fuels

Most plastic bags are made using non-renewable fossil fuels, such as natural gas and petroleum. By banning them, we reduce our reliance on these limited resources and lower our overall carbon footprint. This contributes to broader climate change mitigation goals and supports the global transition to renewable energy.

8. Control of Mosquito-Borne Diseases

Discarded plastic bags trap rainwater, creating ideal breeding grounds for mosquitoes. These mosquitoes can carry harmful viruses such as West Nile Virus and Eastern Equine Encephalitis (EEE). By cutting down on plastic litter, particularly in tropical and subtropical regions, we also help reduce the spread of vector-borne diseases.

Struggling to get your child to express thoughts in an organised, compelling way?
Our writing classes help students master structure, clarity, and impactful writing — perfect for debates, essays, and real-world communication.
Enrol them in PlanetSpark’s English Writing Program and see the change!

The Disadvantages of Plastic Bag Bans

1. Economic Impact on the Plastic Industry

One of the most cited drawbacks of plastic bag bans is the potential economic harm to manufacturers. Plastic bag producers may experience a sharp decline in business and, in some cases, closures. This can result in job losses, particularly in regions heavily reliant on plastic manufacturing. However, many of these job losses can be mitigated through retraining and transitioning workers into sustainable packaging industries.

2. Initial Costs for Consumers

There is a short-term inconvenience and cost to consumers who are accustomed to receiving plastic bags for free. Reusable bags must be purchased, with prices ranging from $1 to $5 depending on material and quality. This can be burdensome, especially for low-income shoppers. However, once the initial investment is made, reusable bags offer long-term durability and cost savings.

3. Hygiene Concerns

Another argument raised against reusable bags is hygiene. Reusable bags, if not washed regularly, may harbor bacteria from raw food or unclean surfaces. Critics argue that plastic bags offer a more sanitary option for transporting items. While the concern is valid, proper public awareness campaigns on washing and caring for reusable bags can significantly minimize this risk.

4. Lack of Uniform Policy

In places where bans are implemented inconsistently, enforcement can be tricky. People might cross into neighboring areas without permits to get plastic bags, which defeats the purpose of the law. For bans to be most effective, nationwide policies or cooperative regional enforcement would be required.

5. Use of Heavier Plastic Alternatives

Some stores replace traditional plastic bags with thicker, heavier plastic alternatives to comply with regulations. Ironically, these thicker bags require more resources to produce and, if not reused enough times, might contribute more to pollution than standard lightweight plastic bags. Therefore, proper legislation must ensure that substitutes are genuinely sustainable and not just more plastic under a new name.

From messy thoughts to structured essays — we help kids find their voice on paper.
Whether it’s debating plastic bans or writing environmental blogs, PlanetSpark teaches your child how to research, write, and revise with purpose.
Start your child’s writing journey here: Try a Free Class

Final Thoughts

When it comes to the plastic bag ban debate, both sides bring valid points to the table. However, the environmental, economic, and health-related advantages of banning single-use plastic bags are far-reaching and well-supported by scientific and economic studies. While the transition may require adaptation and public cooperation, the long-term benefits  cleaner cities, safer oceans, improved wildlife health, and sustainable practices — make a compelling case in favor of bans.

It’s not about eliminating convenience; it’s about embracing responsibility. Small lifestyle changes today can lead to a greener, cleaner planet tomorrow. Whether through government policy or consumer choice, the shift away from plastic bags is already underway and it’s a step in the right direction.