Think from Both Sides: Class 4 Counterarguments in Opinion Writing 

This Grade 4 counterargument worksheet helps students understand that every opinion has more than one side. Through structured and engaging activities, learners practice identifying opposing viewpoints, responding logically, and writing balanced opinion paragraphs. The worksheet strengthens reasoning, clarity, and persuasive writing skills, making it ideal for CBSE English learners developing critical thinking.

 Why Counterarguments Matter in Opinion Writing? 

1. Counterarguments teach students to consider different viewpoints respectfully. 
2. They help learners strengthen their own opinions with logical reasoning. 
3. Understanding opposing ideas improves persuasive and essay writing. 
4. These skills build critical thinking and mature expression in upper primary grades. 

What’s Inside This Worksheet? 

🧠 Exercise 1 – Write a Counterargument 
Students read an opinion and write one counterargument using the starter “But some people say…”. 

🔗 Exercise 2 – Match Opinions with Counterarguments 
Learners match five opinions with the most suitable counterarguments, strengthening reasoning skills. 

✍️ Exercise 3 – Turn Opinions into Counterarguments 
Students rewrite unrealistic or extreme opinions as clear, logical counterarguments. 

🕵️ Exercise 4 – Counterargument Detective Story 
Learners read a short story, identify the opinion and counterargument, give personal views, and add an extra counterargument. 

📝 Exercise 5 – Counterargument Paragraph Challenge 
Students write a full paragraph that includes an opinion, a counterargument, explanation, and a strong conclusion. 

✅ Answer Key (For Parents & Educators) 

Exercise 1 – Write ONE Counterargument 
(Sample answers) 

1. Kids should have extra recess every day. 
But some people say too much recess can reduce study time. 

2. School lunch should always be pizza. 
But some people say eating pizza every day is unhealthy. 

3. Every student should have a pet in the classroom. 
But some people say pets can distract students or cause allergies. 

4. All homework should be removed. 
But some people say homework helps students practice what they learn. 

5. Tablets should replace notebooks. 
But some people say tablets can be expensive and distracting. 

Exercise 2 – Match the Opinion with the Best Counterargument 
Correct matches: 
1 → B 
2 → D 
3 → E 
4 → A 
5 → C 

Exercise 3 – Turn These into Counterarguments 
(Sample answers) 

1. Kids should have no chores. 
However, chores teach responsibility and life skills. 

2. Video games should replace outdoor play. 
But outdoor play keeps children healthy and active. 

3. Students should bring pets to lunch. 
However, pets may cause messes and safety issues. 

4. School days should be only two hours long. 
But two hours is not enough time to learn all subjects. 

5. Kids should eat dessert before meals. 
However, eating dessert first can be unhealthy. 

Exercise 4 – Counterargument Detective Story 
(Sample answers) 

1. Maya’s opinion: School uniforms should be banned. 
2. Rohan’s counterargument: Uniforms help everyone feel equal and avoid distractions. 
3. I agree with Rohan because uniforms reduce comparison among students. 
4. Rohan’s idea would be stronger in an essay because it focuses on fairness and learning. 
5. Another counterargument: Uniforms save time in the morning. 

Exercise 5 – Counterargument Paragraph Challenge 
(Sample answer – Topic: Students should bring snacks to class) 

Students should be allowed to bring snacks to class because it helps them stay energized. Some people say snacks can distract students or make a mess. This might be true sometimes. However, healthy snacks like fruits keep students focused during long lessons. When students are not hungry, they can learn better. That is why bringing snacks to class is a good idea. 

Help your child learn to think critically and write stronger opinions by understanding both sides of an argument. 

🔖Book a free trial!